A dilemma, in logic, is a form of argument in which a participant finds himself in the embarrassing predicament of having to make a choice of either of two premises, both of which are obnoxious.
It is a trap set by an astute person to catch an unwary one, like answering yes or no to the question, “Have you stopped beating yourself up?” Because one may be caught and impaled upon either of the alternatives, each of them has been called a “horn.”
Medieval scholars, writing in Latin, used the expression, argumentum cornutum, horned argument. Nicolas Udall, in his translations of the adages collected (in Latin) by Erasmus explains the saying in the language of 1548:
“Thys forked questyon; which the sophisters call an horned question, because that to whether of both partyes a bodye shall make a direct aunswcre, he shall renne on the sharpe poyncte of the borne.”
Related Posts
-
What does the expression “hair and hide” (horns and tallow) mean and Where does it originate?
The expression "hair and hide" means: The whole works; every part; the entirety. The first part, hair and hide, has long been used in the same sense. In fact, five hundred years ago,…
-
Where does the expression “to take the bull by the horns” come from?
If you have inadvertently insulted your employer's best customer you must eventually "take the bull by the horns", screw your courage to the sticking point, and tell the boss what happened; for we…
-
What does the phrase “to pull in one’s horns” mean and Where does it come from?
The use of the figure of speech "to pull in one's horns" with the meaning, "to retract, or to check oneself," has been traced back to the fourteenth century. The allusion is to…
-
How Did Deer Get His Horns In Cherokee Mythology?
Originally, Deer had a smooth head with no horns. One day, the animals decided to have a contest between Rabbit and Deer to determine who was the fastest. They would race through a…
-
Where does the expression “to come out flat footed” come from and What does it mean?
There are no ands, ifs, nor buts in the statement of one who "comes out flat footed"; you know exactly what he means and where he stands. We picture him as planted firmly…
-
Where does the expression “come off your perch” come from and What does it mean?
The expression "come off your perch" means: come down a peg or two; don't be too conceited, haughty, or arrogant. The allusion is to the twig serving as a resting place for a…
